can you rate my first sig?

[zachmen]

hi, this is my first sig. Can you rate it and tell me what i should do to make it better

 

[Yaszie_123]

Hmmm, that is the best siggy I have ever seen. My love goes to you. Lmao

 

[zachmen]

Really??? Wow thank you!!!!

 

[porky]

omfg he was laughing at it...............u nub!!!!

 

[porky]

omfg he was laughing at it................. u nub!!!!!

 

[thecruiser]

Porky, you can't say shit. You have two goddamn posts. STFU, fucking noob.

And BTW, I cant see the first one Zachman. I can only see the Edge one, which I give an 8/10 on a beginner's scale (If you really did make it).

 

[pastie154]

thats really good considering its your first sig...wel done m8

 

[zachmen]

for your information thecruiser, i really made it.

 

[zachmen]

It was only my second second sig, but i work with photosop for a little while

 

[1789]

Hmmm, that is the best siggy I have ever seen. My love goes to you. Lmao

***. Why do that? Anyways it is really good for a first try. I would take that for mine if i didnt have my own forums. It is a 9.5/10

 

[gycax]

9.5? Dude, I hate to tell you, and I'm going to be constructive, but it's pretty damn poor. Here's why, and here's how to improve it:

1) The filter on thos epics as the BG is hoorendous. Filters should be used sparingly, as they hardly ever help a piece.

2) The DX logo is a little dull, did you blur it? Also, the positioning of it is OK, but it could be better.

3) The border would look better as a 1px black border.

4) Improve the blending. I can see the line where the 2 pictures meet, and that's not cool. Either screen them and put a PSD over the seam, use a mask and blend them in or feather it.

Apart from this, I like the 'Are you ready' text, it fits DX's character, and the pictures you've actually used are decent. The text for the name shouldn't be the same, use a simple, small text, a pixelated one or arial or something.

Overall, it's about a 4/10. But, I can definately see room for improvement. Keep at it.

My first sig was far worse than that and I can churn out far better stuff easily now. Play around and experiment. And sorry if you get offended by any of that criticism, I'm calling it as I see it.

 

[zachmen]

Thanks man for the comments. I just wanna know how do you make your border. I use photoshop elements but i can't find it.

 

[gycax]

Ah, sorry I can't help. I have no idea how elements works. I press control and a on a new laer and go to Edit > Stroke. Might not work for you.

 

[zachmen]

Yes. I found it. thanks dude

 

[Death Knight]

the dx one is pretty good, but its not very clear, i love the other 2 tho...awesome...good work!

 

[thecruiser]

Now that I see the DX, it's OK. 5/10 on a beginner's scale.

And BTW, I was just asking if you actually made that sig. You don't have to snap at me you ingrate.

 

[zachmen]

i'M not an ingrate.lol!!! i was not trying to snap you!!! lol
BTW your sig is reall cool(the cruiser). i like your work

 

[thecruiser]

Which one are you talking about? the "Last Survival" PPV sig or the Petey Williams video sig?

BTW, sry for calling you an ingrate. Im having family troubles right now.