• Xenforo Cloud has scheduled an upgrade to XenForo version 2.2.16. This will take place on or shortly after the following date and time: Jul 05, 2024 at 05:00 PM (PT) There shouldn't be any downtime, as it's just a maintenance release. More info here

Bruno Sammartino: Worthy or Not?

Does Bruno Sammartino deserve to be in the Hall of Fame?

  • Yes. He was greatness before the industry was known.

  • No. He's no Hulk Hogan.


Results are only viewable after voting.

TheOneBigWill

[This Space for Rent]
sammartino-medium.jpg

Bruno Leopoldo Francesco Sammartino (born October 6, 1935) is an Italian former professional wrestler, best known for being the longest-running champion of the World Wide Wrestling Federation (WWWF), holding the title across two reigns for over 11 years in total, as well as the longest single World Heavyweight Championship reign in professional wrestling history.

Sammartino's wrestling ability was more mat-oriented which was typical of wrestlers from his era. His brawling style, power moves, and personal charisma helped him become the most popular American wrestler in the 1960s and 1970s. During the period when Madison Square Garden was the WWWF's primary arena, Sammartino headlined more Garden cards than any other wrestler (130), including 45 sellouts.

Sammartino's first match in the Garden was January 2, 1960 against Bull Curry (who was substituting for Killer Kowalski). Within six months of his debut in wrestling, Sammartino was headlining at Madison Square Garden (starting in tag matches, teaming with Antonino Rocca). During his first year of wrestling, after tiring of low payoffs and broken promises, Sammartino left Vincent McMahon Sr.'s Capitol Wrestling Corporation to join a rival New York promoter and former McMahon Sr. partner Kola Kwariani. Kwariani's hold on New York soon weakened because of low attendance and athletic commission pressure to curb violence. In an effort to increase attendance, Kwariani had Sammartino wrestle his tag partner Antonino Rocca twice during this time. Sammartino was then told by Rudy Miller to jump back to McMahon.

Sammartino found himself with even fewer dates and payoffs than the first time he wrestled for McMahon. He gave notice to McMahon that he was going to San Francisco, and its large Italian population, to wrestle for promoter Roy Shire. Very soon after arriving, Sammartino was informed by the local athletic commission that he was suspended. Unable to find work across the country (because every state athletic commission honors suspensions given by other state athletic commissions), Bruno headed back to Pittsburgh to work as a laborer. Sammartino found out that his suspension was due to his skipping a match he was booked for in Baltimore. He was also booked to wrestle in Chicago that same night. In his autobiography, Sammartino states that he believed McMahon set him up, by double-booking him and not informing him of his match in Baltimore, as a way of punishment for working for Kwariani. After promoters Toots Mondt and McMahon Sr. cleared up Sammartino's suspension by paying his $500 fine, Sammartino went back to work.

On the advice of wrestler Yukon Eric, Bruno contacted Toronto promoter Frank Tunney hoping to take advantage of Toronto's large Italian population. Very quickly, with the help of self-promotion in local newspapers and radio programs, Bruno became a strong attraction in Toronto. With Canadian legend Whipper Billy Watson, Bruno won his first championship, the NWA International Tag Team Championship. Soon, he was in demand by other promoters in different Canadian territories.

On February 18, 1961, Sammartino faced Chick Garibaldi in an afternoon match at the Sunnyside Gardens in New York. During the match, Sammartino bodyslammed Garibaldi and immediately noticed his opponent's eyes roll up inside his head. By the time the ref checked on the fallen wrestler, he was dead in the ring. It was later determined that Garibaldi had died from a heart attack. In the movie Legends Never Die, Sammartino stated that it took him many years to get over that incident.

Back in New York, McMahon Sr. was having a tough time drawing fans with Buddy Rogers. After many weeks of phone calls with McMahon, Sammartino got a title shot for the WWWF World Heavyweight Championship) against Rogers. Even after he won the WWWF Heavyweight Championship, Sammartino still wrestled every other Sunday on the big shows promoted by Tunney. Sammartino made major headlines when he became the first (and only) man to lift 600-pound Haystacks Calhoun in a match and slam him.

He won the WWF World Championship title on May 17, 1963, defeating "Nature Boy" Buddy Rogers in just 48 seconds. Sammartino kept this title for an incredible seven years, eight months, and one day; it still stands as the longest continuous world title reign in men's wrestling history.

Sammartino was so popular that in 1965 he was picked by the National Wrestling Alliance board to defeat Lou Thesz, which would have made him the first wrestler to hold both the NWA and WWWF titles at the same time. Sammartino, already getting only every other weekend off, balked when told that he could expect months of continuous bookings with no time off. NWA officials then selected Gene Kiniski to defeat Thesz.

On September 28, 1965, after a match with Tarzan Tyler in Madison Square Garden, Sammartino went to a restaurant in Times Square. When he returned, he found that a window in his car was shattered and his championship belt, which had been placed in a suitcase, was stolen. The belt, which was valued at $10,000, was uninsured, and was immediately replaced by the WWWF. Sammartino headlined cards that filled Madison Square Garden on a monthly basis. He battled the top bad guys of his time, including Killer Kowalski, Giant Baba, Gene Kiniski, Dr. Bill Miller, Bull Ramos, Hans Mortier, Waldo Von Erich, "Crusher" Reginald Lisowski, Johnny Valentine, The Sheik, Freddie Blassie, Curtis Iaukea, Tarzan Tyler, Bill Watts, Gorilla Monsoon, and George "The Animal" Steele.

On January 18, 1971, Sammartino lost the championship at Madison Square Garden to Ivan Koloff. The crowd was so stunned into silence that Sammartino thought his hearing had been damaged. After the pin, Koloff slowly walked across the ring while the ref raised his hand three times. The announcer came into the ring with the belt but did not present it to Koloff. Koloff left the ring while Sammartino stayed inside to keep the crowd's attention off Koloff. As Sammartino left the ring, people started crying. Sammartino has said that the crowd's reaction disturbed him while he sat in the dressing room after the match.

Two weeks later, Pedro Morales beat Koloff to win the title. While Morales drew well in New York, the crowds declined in other cities. In 1973, Sammartino was asked back by McMahon Sr. After refusing McMahon's initial offer, Sammartino was offered a percentage of all the gates when he wrestled and a decreased work schedule. Soon after, Bruno and champion Morales wrestled in a series of tag matches. In one tag match, Professor Tanaka blinded both men. When their eyes cleared, they kept fighting each other, to the surprise of the crowd. On September 1, 1972, both men wrestled to a 75-minute draw at Shea Stadium in New York. The gate narrowly missed becoming the largest take for an outdoor wrestling show at that time.

On January 14, 1972, Sammartino returned to Los Angeles, California for the first time in five years to participate in the highlight of promoter Mike LeBelle's year: a 22-man battle royal. The battle royal included competitors such as Rocky Johnson, Mil Máscaras, John Tolos, Haystack Calhoun, and Ripper Collins. The final two men left in the ring were Collins and Sammartino. After brawling for about five minutes, they noticed that they were the only ones left. After Sammartino bodyslammed Collins several times, he then applied the bearhug. Collins submitted and Bruno was the champion, and the $11,000 winner, of the third annual Olympic Battle Royal. This battle royal marked the first time that Pro Wrestling Illustrated had fans vote on Match of the Year. It went on to become the Match of the Year for 1972.

Eventually, on December 10, 1973, Sammartino regained the WWWF Championship, defeating Stan Stasiak. He defeated contenders such as John Tolos, Bruiser Brody, Spiros Arion, Ken Patera, Bugsy McGraw, Freddie Blassie, Baron Von Raschke, Waldo Von Erich, Ivan Koloff, "Superstar" Billy Graham, Don Leo Jonathan, Angelo Mosca, Ernie Ladd, and Nikolai Volkoff. His second title run lasted three years, four months, and twenty days.

During this time, on April 26, 1976, Sammartino suffered a neck fracture in a match against Stan Hansen at Madison Square Garden, when Hansen improperly executed a body slam. After two months of recovery, Sammartino returned, and faced Hansen in a rematch on June 25, 1976 at Shea Stadium, which was on the closed circuit TV undercard of the famous Ali vs. Antonio Inoki match for WWWF cities. Sammartino was rushed back into action by Vince McMahon Sr. when the advance gate for the show was a disaster. Sammartino scored a decisive count-out win, after Hansen ran from the ring. More importantly, Sammartino drew a large live audience, and big closed circuit TV receipts (the Ali/Inoki show, without the Sammartino/Hansen match, did horribly in much of the parts of America that did not air the Sammartino/Hansen). The match was rated 1976 Match of the Year by a number of wrestling magazines.

His second title reign was only supposed to last a year but each year Bruno received bigger payoffs to stay on. In early 1977, after suffering a broken neck and many other ailments, Bruno informed McMahon Sr. that he was done with his second title reign. It ended on April 30, 1977, when he was defeated by "Superstar" Billy Graham in a controversial ending. Graham had both feet on the ropes (which is illegal under normal professional wrestling rules) while successfully pinning Sammartino.

After his second reign ended, Bruno toured the U.S. and the world. He wrestled then-NWA Champion Harley Race to a one hour draw. He also beat, among many others, Blackjack Mulligan, Lord Alfred Hayes, and "Crippler" Ray Stevens, and teamed with the legendary Dick the Bruiser to win the WWA Tag Titles from The Valiant Brothers.

One of the most emotional feuds of Bruno's career started on January 22, 1980, when his former student Larry Zbyszko violently turned against him during a scientific exhibition, broadcast on the World Wrestling Federation's Championship Wrestling show. Bruno, shocked and hurt by Zbyszko's betrayal, vowed to make Zbyszko (whom Bruno described as a "Judas") pay dearly. Their feud culminated on August 9, 1980, in front of 36,295 fans at Shea Stadium. As the main event of 1980's Showdown at Shea, Bruno defeated Zbyszko inside a steel cage. This feud is considered by many wrestling historians and journalists to be the biggest feud in the history of wrestling in the northeast.

Sammartino finds Hulk Hogan's claim in his autobiography that he and André the Giant were the reason for the Shea gate to be humorous. The feud between Sammartino and Zbyszko sold out everywhere they wrestled leading up the show. Hogan and Andre wrestled in White Plains, New York, drawing 1,200 in a building that held 3,500 as the main event before they wrestled at Shea.

After retiring from wrestling full-time in 1981, Sammartino agreed to return to the then-WWF in an attempt to launch the wrestling career of his son David, who became a wrestler against his father's wishes. Sammartino wrestled occasionally, teaming with his son against the likes of Paul Orndorff and Bobby Heenan and Brutus Beefcake and Johnny Valiant. David soon realized he was being used by Vince McMahon to get his famous father to wrestle (and draw huge crowds in the northeast). Disenchanted, David quit the WWF several times which forced Sammartino to continue to wrestle, in hopes that he could get his son back in McMahon's good graces.

It was during this time that Sammartino found out through Angelo Savoldi, an ex-employee of Capitol Wrestling Corp., that he was being cheated by Vince McMahon Sr. on the gate percentages that he was promised. Bruno filed suit in 1979 against McMahon Sr. and Capitol Wrestling.

The suit was settled out of court by McMahon Jr. after his father had died. Part of the settlement included Bruno doing color commentary on the WWF TV show. Sammartino's last major run came during the mid-1980s, following the inaugral WrestleMania in 1985. At that event, Sammartino chaperoned his son, David, in his match against Brutus Beefcake. That match ended in a double-disqualification after the Sammartinos began brawling with Beefcake and Johnny Valiant.

Sammartino has stated many times that he was coaxed out of retirement by his son David in order for David to receive a push from McMahon Jr. Sammartino says that this time period was his least favorite of his career.

Sammartino's most notable feud during this run was with "Macho Man" Randy Savage. He often teamed with Tito Santana and even old enemy George "The Animal" Steele to wrestle Savage and "Adorable" Adrian Adonis. The feud intensified in late 1986 and early 1987 when an irate Sammartino attacked Savage during a TV interview, after Savage bragged about injuring Ricky Steamboat (by driving the timekeeper's bell into Steamboat's throat during a televised match). Sammartino also defeated Savage in a lumberjack match for the WWF Intercontinental Championship (via disqualification, allowing Savage to keep the belt).

In late 1985 and early 1986, Sammartino engaged in a feud with Rowdy Roddy Piper after Piper insulted him on Piper's Pit at Madison Square Garden; "Cowboy" Bob Orton had tried to stay in the ring in an attempt to intimidate Sammartino, but the ploy did not work. The "Living Legend" got the upper hand in the feud, ultimately defeating Piper in a steel cage match at the Boston Garden. Sammartino also competed in the battle royal at WrestleMania 2, but didn't win.

Sammartino's last major series of matches came in the summer of 1987 against The Honky Tonk Man for the Intercontinental Title. Although he dominated the matches against the champion Honky, Sammartino never won the title, winning most of his matches by countout or disqualification. Sammartino also fought in a series of matches against Hercules during this time. Bruno had his last singles match against Hercules Hernandez. He won via countout at the Paul Boesch Retirement Show in Houston, Texas on August 28, 1987.

Sammartino's final WWF match saw him team with Hulk Hogan to defeat King Kong Bundy and One Man Gang. He continued doing commentary on the WWF's syndicated Superstars of Wrestling until March 1988.

After leaving the WWF, Sammartino began doing commentary for the Universal Wrestling Federation as it attempted to go national and compete with the WWF, the NWA, the WCCW, and Jim Crockett Promotions.

On October 28, 1989, Bruno made a special appearance at the NWA PPV Halloween Havoc, where he was the special guest referee in a "Thunderdome" cage match which featured Ric Flair and Sting taking on Terry Funk and The Great Muta. He ended up exchanging blows with Muta at the end of the match and ran him off. He appeared at several WCW events in a minor analysis role in the early 1990s. His list of accomplishments and Championships (according to Wiki) are as follows:

Grand Prix Wrestling
GPW Tag Team Championship (1 time) - with Édouard Carpentier

Maple Leaf Wrestling
NWA World Heavyweight Championship (1 time)
NWA International Tag Team Championship (Toronto version) (1 time) - with Whipper Billy Watson
NWA United States Heavyweight Championship (Toronto version) (1 time)

Pro Wrestling Illustrated
Match of the Year (1972) Battle royal on January 14, Los Angeles, CA
Match of the Year (1975) vs. Spiros Arion on March 17, New York, NY
Match of the Year (1976) vs. Stan Hansen on April 26, New York, NY
Match of the Year (1977) vs. Billy Graham on April 30, Baltimore, MD
Match of the Year (1980) vs. Larry Zbyszko at Showdown at Shea in a steel cage match
Most Inspirational Wrestler of the Year (1976)
Stanley Weston Award (1981)
Wrestler of the Year (1974)
Professional Wrestling Hall of Fame and Museum
(Class of 2002)

World Wrestling Association
WWA World Tag Team Championship (1 time) - with Dick the Bruiser

World Wide Wrestling Federation | World Wrestling Federation
WWF International Tag Team Championship (2 times) - with Dominic DeNucci {1) and Tony Marino (1)
WWWF United States Tag Team Championship (1 time) - with Spiros Arion
WWWF Championship (2 times)

Wrestling Observer Newsletter awards
Feud of the Year (1980) vs. Larry Zbyszko
Wrestling Observer Newsletter Hall of Fame (Class of 1996)
Awards
Madison Square Garden walk of fame
Received Key to the City in Franklin, PA as part of IWC's Night of Legends 3 on March 24, 2007.
World Wide Wrestling Alliance (WWWA) Hall of Fame 1st inductee - 11/7/2008

Bruno Sammartino: Unfortunately, much in the similar ways of Bob Backlund, I clearly wasn't alive during the Bruno Sammartino era and to add to it, I haven't seen hardly any of his matches to clearify if I would personally have liked him or not. Just on the understanding that we live in a different time and a different era, I would likely find it hard to sit through some of the mat-wars and ultimate classics that were Sammartino's matches. Not by any means because they would be bad, but instead because it was a vastly different time period then.

The one positive factor is that I'm a 26, going on 27 year old individual with a passion for this business, capable of realizing how great this man was to have not yet been inducted into the W.W.E. Hall of Fame, and I'm gappingly unsure why. According to wiki, he's one of if not the single most impressive Heavyweight Champion of all-time, for holding the title the longest. (2 reigns over the span of 11 years combined.)

My assumption is that in some weird and stupid way of respecting Hulk Hogan as being the guy that "built" the World Wrestling Federation, they wouldn't want to up-stage Hogan by adding a guy that's Heavyweight reigns would make Hogan's look ultimately like, say, Punk's. (clearly not the case though)

For no other reason that Bruno Sammartino is already an icon in my mind, and a legend to add-on, I would definately induct him. But I couldn't say with any certainty that I'd do it for knowing his career as well as I could for several others. What are your thoughts and opinions on Bruno Sammartino being a Hall of Fame inductee? Worthy or Not?
 
If there has ever been a definite yes then this is it. He was the World Heavyweight champion over 10 years total. We live in the year 2009. Flash back ten years. ECW was still around, WCW was still around, we would be going into WM 15, and Austin and HHH had never been world champion. In all that time since then, imagine if one person held the title. That's how long his reigns were in total. That's simply mind blowing to even think about. Today we freak over Cena's year long run. Multiply that times 7 and you have Sammartino's. This man sold out the world's most famous arena something liek 100 times, which is more than Hulk did. For him not to be in is an outright crime. Put the man in the HOF already.
 
My answer is no. Why? Well, I'll answer that and Will's question at the same time.

Based upon his merits and career, there is no doubt he has the credentials. What he DOESN'T have is the love for the wrestling business as it is run today. He wants no part of it. He seems to think that everything the WWE does is crap, and he denounces them at every turn. This is the company that made him a superstar, and gave him great money, and in return, he does nothing but bad mouth them. That's why Bruno isn't in the Hall of Fame, Will, because he doesn't want to be associated with the WWE at all.

So, whether you take Bruno's side, or the WWE's side, or a little of both, when you figure in the fact that neither side will ever change, I don't think Bruno should be in the Hall. He doesn't want to be, and he criticizes the product of the company who would induct him.

So, no, to Bruno.
 
Yes Bruno Sammartino should be in the Hall Of Fame.All one has to do is look at his career & it's plain to see that's where he belongs.But it's sad to say he more than likely would turn it down. With his feelings on present day wrestling.And how he feels about McMahan I personally don't see him ever accepting the invitation. We know how he feels about Vince McMahan & the WWE.It's a shame cause he has every right to be in the Hall Of Fame.He should of been ne f the first to be inducted into it.
 
From what i have heard is that the reason he isnt in the Hall of Fame is because he doesn't want to be. as he has been offered the spot almost every year since WM 20, but when he found out that Pete Rose eas being inducted he say it as a very big insult.

But does he deserve to be in the Hall of Fame...... HELL YEAH!!!!!!

so he disowns what ever the WWE. that doesn't matter he has been one of the biggest drawers in wrestling. and he was that good in his time that he held the Belt for 10+ (no one would be given the belt for that long if they didnt draw that good.

I remember when i first started to research the WWF/E Title history and when i saw Bruno i was absoultly stunned when it said 7 years. when i told my fellow wrestling friends they didnt believe me at all. i had to print out the a copy of the website to prove it.
 
My answer is no. Why? Well, I'll answer that and Will's question at the same time.

Based upon his merits and career, there is no doubt he has the credentials. What he DOESN'T have is the love for the wrestling business as it is run today. He wants no part of it. He seems to think that everything the WWE does is crap, and he denounces them at every turn. This is the company that made him a superstar, and gave him great money, and in return, he does nothing but bad mouth them. That's why Bruno isn't in the Hall of Fame, Will, because he doesn't want to be associated with the WWE at all.

So, whether you take Bruno's side, or the WWE's side, or a little of both, when you figure in the fact that neither side will ever change, I don't think Bruno should be in the Hall. He doesn't want to be, and he criticizes the product of the company who would induct him.

So, no, to Bruno.

I agree 100%.

If they were to only count credentials then yes,

BUT Why in the blue hell would someone like that deserve to be in the hall of fame.He does bad mouth vince and his company and pro wrestling overall everytime he gets a chance.He looks down upon todays wrestling because he thinks that his era was way better.well that may be true according to his opinion.Also i wouldnt be surprised if he looked down on todays fans because they enjoy what they are watching over videos of of him and other wrestlers back in the day.

So my vote is a NO.
 
Bruno is definatly worthy of the HOF and is in the REAL PWHOF in NY nestled nicely with all of the greats in this business. Bruno is as worthy as any great talent this sport has ever seen, he WAS one of the greats of the 60's and 70's, it reminds me a lot of Hogan/Flair......

In the 80's, Hogan carried the banner for WWF and Flair for the NWA, same in the 60's with Lou Thez and Bruno Sammartino.

My answer is no. Why? Well, I'll answer that and Will's question at the same time.

Based upon his merits and career, there is no doubt he has the credentials. What he DOESN'T have is the love for the wrestling business as it is run today. He wants no part of it. He seems to think that everything the WWE does is crap, and he denounces them at every turn. This is the company that made him a superstar, and gave him great money, and in return, he does nothing but bad mouth them. That's why Bruno isn't in the Hall of Fame, Will, because he doesn't want to be associated with the WWE at all.

So, whether you take Bruno's side, or the WWE's side, or a little of both, when you figure in the fact that neither side will ever change, I don't think Bruno should be in the Hall. He doesn't want to be, and he criticizes the product of the company who would induct him.

So, no, to Bruno.

I will take sides with both Bruno and the WWE but the HOF shouldn't be weather or not you respect the business today, it should be more of a achievement of what you did when you were active. Screw the WWE HOF, thee REAL HOF is where it's at!
 
In my view, Sammartino deserves to be inducted more than many of the WWE Hall of Famers and some of the inductees this year. Sammartino is the longest reigning World Champion in the history of the business and he was the biggest draw in the WWWF during the 60s and most of the 70s. As far as him bad mouthing the business, the man's entitled to his opinion. Vince McMahon has rubbed a LOT of people in the wrestling industry the wrong way. He's run people out of it, he's put promotions out of business that ran for decades, he's a raving ego maniac that would very much love to be able to write history and claim that the WWE is the only wrestling promotion in world history if he could. The topic isn't really if he'll ever be inducted, which I doubt he will because he's reportedly turned down numerous requests to be inducted, but whether or not he's worthy. A lot of the old timers don't like what wrestling has become, but that doesn't diminish their contributions to the industry one bit. His dislike of the business today doesn't take away the fact that he carried the old WWWF for roughly 15 years.
 
He was the second ever WWE/WWF/WWWF Champion and held it for 7 years before losing it to Antonio Inoki and just a few years later, he regained it and held it for another 4 years, thats why I voted yes
 
This is a no brainer, of course Bruno should be in the HOF, the WWE seems to agree 100% too. Bruno doesn't though, he's an old timer that refuses to accept changes and harbors resentment for the WWE. Someday, after he's passed on, he will be inducted, because it's just the right thing to do.
 
This is a no brainer, of course Bruno should be in the HOF, the WWE seems to agree 100% too. Bruno doesn't though, he's an old timer that refuses to accept changes and harbors resentment for the WWE. Someday, after he's passed on, he will be inducted, because it's just the right thing to do.

Exactly right. The question posed in this topic has two sides to it.

(1)-Do his career accomplishments merit induction?.............Obviously, they do.

(2)-Should he be inducted?..............Not in my opinion.


We shouldn't make the mistake of trying to compare today's wrestling era to Bruno's. There was no PPV, no merchandising, no worldwide exposure...... it was a different product altogether and Bruno Sammartino was the dominant figure. Little old grandmothers in New York City knew who he was.

But I can't see inducting a man who would refuse induction. If he puts out a press release denouncing WWE in the days before the ceremony, how foolish would the company look?

Kurgen said it best; Wait until he dies, and induct him posthumously. It will save WWE from embarrassment while coming off as a classy move.

By the way, it's a shame. There is an industry waiting to honor him and he behaves like a stubborn old fool and deprives us and himself of it.
 
He was the second ever WWE/WWF/WWWF Champion and held it for 7 years before losing it to Antonio Inoki and just a few years later, he regained it and held it for another 4 years, thats why I voted yes

Just to add a correction here, Bruno Sammartino never lost the title to Antonio Inoki. Bruno lost the title the first time to Ivan Koloff in 1971. A few weeks later, Pedro Morales beat Koloff for the title and held it for two years, before losing it to Stan Stasiak. Stasiak held the title for about a week before losing it back to Bruno, who held it for another four years, before losing to Billy Graham in 1977. You're probably thinking of Bob Backlund who lost the title to Antoni Inoki in 1979 in Japan. Bob then beat him a week later and came back to the States as the champion. Thus the title change wasn't acknowledged by WWE in America, which is why Bob is today listed by WWE as a 2 time WWE Champion, when in fact, he's a 3 time champion.

But anyways, as to the subject at hand, whether Bruno is worthy of being in the HOF. Frankly, that's got to be a question with an obvious answer. Of course Bruno Sammartino is deserving of being in the HOF. Short of perhaps Hulk Hogan, Ric Flair, and Stone Cold Steve Austin, there isn't anyone in WWE history that has more credentials and is thus more deserving of being in the WWE HOF than Bruno Sammartino.

Bruno is one of the biggest draws in WWE history, and certainly the biggest draw of the first era of the WWE (when it was known as the WWWF). I don't think I really need to discuss his credentials too much as that has already been done obviously.

When I first saw Sly saying no, my jaw dropped. I thought to myself, "How could anyone possibly think he's not deserving of being in the HOF?" But after reading Sly's argument (and the other people that agreed), I do see their point, but ultimately, I still think despite his negative opinions of the wrestling industry today and WWE and Vince himself, Bruno still deserves it.

Bruno isn't a case on the level of Chris Benoit in that he's done something so unforgivable he'll never deserve it. Granted Bruno was a force in the late '80s and early '90s when the goverment were investigating the WWE, and the media was looking down on WWE due to the steriod and sexual misconduct issues and scandals going on. But so was "Superstar" Billy Graham and even Hulk Hogan made the WWE and Vince look bad during the steriod trial. And Vince forgave those guys and they're both HOFers now. Bruno's done a lot to damage the reputation of pro wrestling today by his speaking out on the issues of wrestling (though I agree with some of his stances), which I'm sure has hurt Vince on a personal level believe it or not (as I'm sure Vince was decently close with Bruno at one point, beings Bruno was his dad's top hand and performer).

But talking crap about Vince and WWE and the wrestling industry itself is nowhere near on the level of murdering your wife and child. Chris Benoit did more to hurt the WWE and the wrestling industry on the final 2-3 days of his life than Bruno ever did in his almost 25-year long "crusade" against the ills and problems of pro wrestling today.

But my mentality about being worthy of induction into a HOF (for anything) is that a person's abilities and achievements in their profession is what matters. We're not talking about the "Humanitarian and Good, Upstanding Morals Hall of Fame." It's the WWE HOF. So whether Chris Benoit murdered his family, or Bruno Sammartino takes verbal cheap-shots at pro wrestling any chance he gets, or Hulk Hogan and his family issues and jokingly talking about killing his wife, whatever, that stuff doesn't equate to whether they belong in a pro wrestling HOF. Michael Jackson might molest kids, but that shouldn't take away from him being in a music HOF, as in the music world, he's one of the biggest and most influential musical artists of all-time. Ike Turner may have beat Tina half to death, but no one can deny that he was an early pioneer of rock and roll music and was one of the great guitar players of the 1950's, and that the Ike and Tina Turner Revue were a legendary group, and thus he's deserving of being in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Once again, this isn't the "Humanitarian HOF." This is a HOF about a person's respective professions and in this case the WWE HOF (a pro wrestling HOF). It should be about pro wrestling and their achievements in the industry. Not how they conduct themselves in their personal lives. Again, save that for a "Humanitarian HOF."

And thus Bruno Sammartino despite his badmouthing of the industry, is still deserving of the HOF. He should have his own wing, if WWE ever actually builds such a building (which I'm sure they will somewhere down the line).

The problem is that Bruno doesn't want to have anything to do with it. Which of course isn't Vince's or WWE's fault. They can't force him to accept. I guess they could induct him anyway without him being there, but that would seem kind of silly and lackluster and would probably create for more drama and negative publicity, and make the HOF less legitimate (which is a problem it has already, but that's another issue for another time).

Bruno Sammartino isn't one of those cases where "WTF is taking WWE so long in inducting him? Are they crazy?" They've tried on numerous occassions.

So I do see why Sly says he shouldn't be inducted. He doesn't want the induction anyway. So why bother? But the question here though is "Is Bruno deserving?" Of course he's deserving. It's just more or less kind of pointless to induct him I guess.

Although they'll probably wait until after he passes on, then induct him posthumously, like someone else mentioned before. Unless they can somehow convince him to do it before that happens, which hopefully will be many years from now.
 
Very much worthy. Bruno Sammartino had one the longest title reigns of all time and no matter what beef he has with Vince, it should be over looked and he and his career in the business before it was known and before Hulk Hogan came along. If the WWE Hall of Fame ever wants to become more credible, they need to induct Sammartino. He worthy and LONG overdue.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Members online

No members online now.

Forum statistics

Threads
174,826
Messages
3,300,735
Members
21,726
Latest member
chrisxenforo
Back
Top