Tim Tebow
Tim Tebow is proof that hard work and determination can only take you so far. Yes he was a winner in college and yes he is one of the greatest players to ever play college football. What he did at Florida was nothing short of remarkable. He led and willed his team to victory on numerous occasions.
However, when it comes to the NFL all of that means jack shit. There have been tons of college football legends and Heisman Trophy winners who have been complete failures in the NFL. The reason? It is a completely different game. The things that made Tebow successful in college have not and are not going to transition to the NFL game. He does not have the talent to be a successful starting quarterback in the NFL. He has been in the league for two years and made 5 career starts yet I have seen absolutely zero progression from him as a passer.
Tebow is inaccurate on nearly every throw and he is constantly making horrible decisions. You can blame the O line and the talent around him all you want but the fact of the matter is, he is no better talent wise then his teammates. He has had plenty of open receivers that he has missed because of inaccuracy. He has had plenty of missed opportunities because of horrible reads. Any success he has had in his last two starts has come at the end of the games because of the type of defense that teams switch to.
His Miami comeback was nice but was made a whole hell of a lot easier due to the "prevent us from winning" defense the Dolphins played. And while Tebow threw two td passes at the end of the game lets not act like he was making miraculous throws in tight spaces. He was making easy throws to his play makers who did the rest. Nice comeback and nice win but against the win less Dolphins and their secondary which is one of the worst in the league, I'm not impressed by the overall performance.
Against an actual good team in Detroit he was abysmal. The protection wasn't great but that's again more excuses for him. He still had open receivers that he missed. He still made poor reads, and he still held the ball for too long. He had plenty of chances to make plays but he failed to do so because of one reason. HE IS NOT A GOOD NFL QUARTERBACK. In fact he isn't even an average NFL quarterback. Again his his stats were somewhat padded because of the late game situation. This time it was mostly Lions backups playing base defense.
I'm not saying he doesn't have talent as a football player and I'm not saying he can't be a productive player in this league. I'm just pointing out the obvious and that is that he is never going to be a productive qb. The best thing for Tebow is to get out of Denver, go to a team with veteran leadership, and make the switch to an H back/tight end hybrid. The sooner everyone realizes that this just isn't going to work out the better. It takes a special talent both physically and mentally to be a successful qb in the NFL. Tebow may be the second coming of Christ as a human being and a talented athlete but none of that is going to make him a good quarterback.