I agree with IC, I really prefer a variation of ways to finish the match.
While I've never considered the match to be less boring due to the fact that someone had a long livid tough match where it ended with a finisher, because in the end, for the majority of times, the finisher in it self is a wow factor to experience, moves like the Shooting Star Press, the RKO, or a Frog Splash, it doesn't matter what move it is, if it's flashy or if it's simple and effective, I still consider them to be a focus point of the match, without taking too much from the remainder of the match.
But on the other side, I am by far not against a match finishing with a normal move, all depending on how the match has progressed, I would be annoyed if it's a squash match to end with a non finishing move, but a match that has been absolutely brutal, I could live with a finish through a DDT, or a normal regular match finishing with a DDT on the floor is just fine as well, due to the brutality of the way it's finished.
I could really go on about every single thing and how it's finished, but when it all comes down to it, I don't mind either way of finishing the match, as long as it's done without it seeming fake, like a squash or like a legitimate upset that doesn't serve a purpose of putting anybody over, but merely buries someone.