First, I’m going to say that I’m a fan of all 6 of these Superstars. 3 of them are in my Top 5, Triple H is in my Top 10, Undertaker is in my Top 20, and Brock is in my Top 25.
I’m going to go with Chris Jericho and I’m going to try to use the “5Ws and an H” method to explain.
What – The Undisputed WWF / WCW World Heavyweight Championship. Let’s face it, when he won it, it was winning 1st and 2nd place at the same time, he’s that damn good. As far as I know, the “Bad Guy” never won BIG like this before in the history of “Bad Guys”. The Top Two World Tiles, in the same night.
When – WrestleMania X8. The first (and only) WM where the WWF / WCW Undisputed Championship was defended. Granted he lost it to Vince Jr. 2.0, but he walked in with the WWF Title, the WCW Title, and his wife.
Where – From San Diego to Atlanta to Milwaukee to Toronto and everywhere in-between, Jericho defended that Title similar to the ways of the Nature Boy, Ric Flair, by any means necessary / by hook or by crook.
Who – He beat the Rock twice. He beat Austin twice. He beat the Rock and Austin both on the same night. Ric Flair can’t say he beat Sting and Lex Lugar both on the same night for the US and WCW Title. Macho Man can’t say he beat Hulk Hogan and Ultimate Warrior both on the same night for the IC and WWF Title. You get the point.
Why – Because Triple H was injured my @$$...well it may have played a part in it, but then who would Hunter have faced at WM X8…who would have won the Rumble in 02, Angle??
…And of course, a…
How – with the help of Vince McMahon, Booker T., Lance Storm, Christian, Nick Patrick, Scott Hall, Kevin Nash, Hulk Hogan, Chris Jericho went on to be the longest reigning Undisputed Champion for 2 days short of 100. I guess the “How” doesn’t help with the point, but to point out Jericho held the two Titles the longest.
There you have it.