Separate names with a comma.
Discussion in '2011 Forum Awards' started by JGlass, Dec 4, 2011.
This was verbatim what I was going to post
Outside of the nominees, you twit.
Did you forget someone?
And who won that year? Does anyone ELSE remember?
Ah. I misinterpreted.
I throw it out there mostly facetiously. I mean, really, I came in like fourth place, but the polling system was full of fuck and IC25 decided Murfish and I were co-RoY.
I just listed guys who joined in March 2009. My point was in that one month alone we had more quality rookies than this entire year. Although I'm sure there are many we're overlooking that didn't receive nomination.
Don't avoid the question...
Gunslinger. I've yet to see a bad post from this kid. To be fair, I haven't seen nearly as many posts from the other candidates as I have with JW, but that may be indicitive of just exactly why he deserves this award. GSB is usually pretty funny, but I don't know that that alone merits a vote for him.
All right, Gunslinger's clearly the best overall poster here. But, since he already has enough votes, GSB gets mine. You're still going to rightfully win, JW, so my vote really isn't important. If GSB was more than ten votes ahead of you, I would have given my vote to you.
I'll vote for Dragon Saga since JW already has this in the bag. I think that TDS and JW are actually more or less equally good, at least in the non spam wrestling sections. TDS is a bit less frequent so that does not play well in his favor.
GSB is also a pretty chill guy but for me personally he stands a bit below JW and TDS. He is funny but there are like 10 guys funnier than him here.
This was definitely one of the hardest choices out of all of the options. George Steele's Barber is very good, and of course, JWGunslinger is awesome in his own regard. But in a tight race, I gave the slight nod to The Dragon Saga.
Ladies and Gentlemen, is this really who you want as your ROTY?
JWGunslinger. Good kid, mediocre poster.
While we didn't have a ton of quantity in this year's rookie crop, we did have a ton of quality. All of these guys were great choices, but JWG got the win. Congratulations JWG, you are 2011's Rookie of the Year!