This was a tricky one, but in the end I went with Billy Graham. He was a pretty charismatic dude who held major hardware many years ago. In contrast, you have Taz who was a big deal in ECW, but let's face it, how much of an accomplishment is this really? ECW was only relevant in the minds of a few guys who give it far more credit than it ever earned in my opinion. Plus, his career was unfortunately far shorter than it should/could have been due to injury, again limiting the impact he was able to have. Taz may have been a submission machine, but in the end, I see the Superstar cheating to win and going over Taz.
