11 Super Mario Bros. 3 (NES) v 43 Soul calibur

[Lee]

Who wins? You decide

 

[E7]

SC was a decent game, but SMB3 is the second best mario game ever. The world, the levels, omg it was so fucking amazing...It def has to win here, vote smb3

 

[X]

Soul Calibur was more than decent, it was amazing. One of the very best fighting games ever created. Unfortunately I'm not a very big fan of fighters outside of the big franchises, and I just don't think the genre itself can compare to one such as the platformer in terms of gameplay or artistic merits.

SMB 3, while also not my favorite Mario game, was a classic. I don't think it deserves as high of a seeding as it's gotten, but it deserves to go over Soul Calibur here.

 

[Ty Burna]

I voted Soul Calibur, well one of the 2 people that voted for Soul Calibur, and that's only because I just decided to be on a semi personal vendetta to try and knock off some sort of Mario game here. I know SMB3, classic game, it's a legend blah blah blah, but I would prefer to play Soul Calibur over it at this point in my life. I don't really have a reason otherwise.

 

[Lee]

SMB3 wins