I'm going with Shinsuke.
Has Kevin Nash ever had a "great" match? I mean for fuck's sake; he was always a neat presence before and after matches, while his actual matches have nothing to do with his legacy. I remember him lawn darting Rey into a trailer, being Shawn's bodyguard and the fingerpoke. I can't, for the life of me, vividly remember a moment from a Kevin Nash match that speaks well of his role as a wrestler.
Shinsuke is the polar opposite. He hasn't had very many supplemental moments, but his ring work is fucking amazing. He's unique in all the best ways, and it's my understanding that he was the inspiration behind Bray Wyatt's ring mannerisms. Shinsuke would make the match look amazing, in spite of having to carry a lumbering injury prone self-obsessed jack-off like Kevin Nash.
There is nothing either good or bad, but thinking makes it so. - Hamlet