WWE & TNA Forum
Wrestling News
Loading...


Go Back   WrestleZone Forums > Wrestling - Non Spam Sections > Old School Wrestling
Register FAQ Members List Calendar Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read
Arcade vBookie

Reply
 
Thread Tools Search this Thread Display Modes
  #1  
Old 06-29-2017, 11:13 AM
SSJPhenom's Avatar
SSJPhenom SSJPhenom is offline
The Phenom of WZ
WCW TV Champion
 
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Las Vegas, Nevada
Age: 29
Posts: 1,733
SSJPhenom scored a win over Santino Marella...SSJPhenom scored a win over Santino Marella...SSJPhenom scored a win over Santino Marella...SSJPhenom scored a win over Santino Marella...SSJPhenom scored a win over Santino Marella...SSJPhenom scored a win over Santino Marella...SSJPhenom scored a win over Santino Marella...SSJPhenom scored a win over Santino Marella...SSJPhenom scored a win over Santino Marella...SSJPhenom scored a win over Santino Marella...SSJPhenom scored a win over Santino Marella...
Send a message via MSN to SSJPhenom
Default Starrcade 1997: The Real Thing That Killed WCW

I know that over the years the death of WCW and Starrcade 97 have been discussed around here ad nauseam. I don't see the two things ever being discussed together, however. So, with this thread, that's what I want to do because it is in my humble opinion that Starrcade 1997 is the first of many things that led to the destruction of WCW.

Starrcade 97 should have been the event that put WCW so far ahead of WWF that it would have been impossible for WWF to come back. At this point in time WCW had already been more than a year undefeated in the ratings war between Nitro and Raw. Sure, Stone Cold Steve Austin, DX, and other things were starting to get some traction in WWF, however, nobody was paying any attention. Then we come to Starrcade on December 28, 1997. An event that was 18 months in the making. Everything leading up to this night had been done just about as well as anyone could've done it.

In the fall of 96 WCW had the whole Sting controversy where he seemingly attacked Lex Luger in the parking lot a week before Fall Brawl. It was a fake Sting but all of the WCW guys didn't trust Sting anymore so this lead to Sting no longer wearing the bright loud colors and being the all American hero. Instead, he would take on a darker tone, hang out in the rafters during events, and wear nothing but black and white. For awhile after this transformation, it was a mystery as to who's side Sting was really on. Every once in awhile he would come down to the ring with his trademark bat and hand it to someone and then turn his back on that person (I never got that). It wasn't until Sting finally attacked the nWo did we know for sure that he was still one of the good guys. For months J.J. Dillion would offer Sting contracts to fight various wrestlers only for Sting to turn them down. Of course Sting would do things like hold up a fan's sign that said Sting wants Hogan and point to a crowd chanting Hogan while Dillion was asking Sting who he wanted to wrestler but of course Dillion just didn't know how to make Sting happy.

Finally, though, the match is made and we get to Starrcade 1997. This is the night that WCW has been waiting for. Hell, this is the night that any wrestling fan worth their salt has been waiting for. Sting vs. Hogan; a match that we had never seen at this point and absolutely the biggest match that WCW still had on the table and it is a complete and utter clusterfuck failure. I'm not going to go over the rest of the show because the, to be honest, it wasn't much better than Sting vs. Hogan. I'm just going to talk about this one match. As I talked about above, the WCW had spent about 18 months building up to this match. By the time Starrcade 97 rolled around it's not a stretch to say that Sting was far and away the most popular babyface in all of wrestling and that Hogan was probably the heel with the most heat. So they had been doing something right going into the show.

Let's talk about what they should've done and what the fans wanted to see. Sting finally get his hands on Hogan, beat the ever loving shit out of him, and win the WCW championship. That's all they had to do with this match and it would've been a success. Is that what they did? Well, obviously not because I wouldn't be making this thread if they did. No, instead we got a match of Hogan completely dominating Sting, dropping the leg on him, and pinning him for the three count. Of course, that was supposed to be a fast three count but it wasn't. It wasn't even kind of fast. It was a normal, run of the mill 3 count. So the fans in the arena and the ones watching at home are completely shocked because to everyone watching it appeared that Hogan had just beaten Sting and easily. So then we get Bret Hart coming in saying that he's not going to let it happen again and yet again, the fans are confused because what happened? He's not going to let people be pinned with a normal 3 count again? So he restarts the match, Sting hits a couple Stinger Splashes, and then he hooks in the Scorpion Death Lock. Then all of a sudden, Hart points to the time keeper to ring the bell and the match is over, Sting has won the title. What? When did Hogan tap out? Well, he never tapped out. Instead, I guess, he verbally gave up. Yet again, the fans are confused and at this point nobody knows what's going on.

So what happened? Well, Hogan happened. He was originally supposed to go into the match and lose clean to Sting. Of course, though, that didn't work for him brother. So he used his creative control card and changed the finish. Now, I'm not sure whether he had played that card before that point in WCW, however, I am sure that this was the first major incident in which he did and it wasn't the last. Ultimately, instead of being the knockout blow to the WWF that it should've been, Starrcade 97 ended up being the first wound to WCW that allowed WWF to ultimately get back in the fight, mount a comeback, and win. Don't get me wrong, Starrcade was a financial success. It was the highest grossing PPV in wrestling history at the time, but the suck ass show and screwy finish turned a lot of fans off to WCW. I am one of those fans. I had probably been watching WCW over WWF for about 8 months at the time of Starrcade 97. When that clusterfuck went down, though, I started watching WWF again and they just kept getting better and better. So I never turned back to WCW. At least, not as religiously as I did in the past.

So what killed WCW? It was a bunch of things, however, Starrcade 97 was the first and may have been the most important factor that led to the demise of WCW.
__________________
Credit: Theo

Quote:
Originally Posted by NightShiftLegend View Post
Thus why I'd let a girl put on a strap-on and get in there. You only live once.
sendpm.gif Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 06-29-2017, 12:28 PM
Deoxyribonucleic A.C.I.D.'s Avatar
Deoxyribonucleic A.C.I.D. Deoxyribonucleic A.C.I.D. is offline
Kamehamehaaaaa!!
WWF Hardcore Champion
 
Join Date: Jul 2011
Location: Thessaloniki, Greece
Age: 21
Posts: 1,151
Deoxyribonucleic A.C.I.D. scored a win over Santino Marella...Deoxyribonucleic A.C.I.D. scored a win over Santino Marella...Deoxyribonucleic A.C.I.D. scored a win over Santino Marella...Deoxyribonucleic A.C.I.D. scored a win over Santino Marella...Deoxyribonucleic A.C.I.D. scored a win over Santino Marella...Deoxyribonucleic A.C.I.D. scored a win over Santino Marella...Deoxyribonucleic A.C.I.D. scored a win over Santino Marella...Deoxyribonucleic A.C.I.D. scored a win over Santino Marella...Deoxyribonucleic A.C.I.D. scored a win over Santino Marella...Deoxyribonucleic A.C.I.D. scored a win over Santino Marella...Deoxyribonucleic A.C.I.D. scored a win over Santino Marella...
Default

Add the fact that one month before WWE went so low as to screw a wrestling legend and fans were just pissed for that, it would have been a walk in the park. I never understood what Hogan had to gain by doing this. He was the freaking heel and had been dominant ever since Bash at the Beach 1996. I mean, what more did he want? Even if he wanted Goldberg to be the one to beat him clean, he should have at least made Sting look equal to all of the NWO, have Sting fall like a true hero.
sendpm.gif Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 06-29-2017, 02:08 PM
neildittmar neildittmar is offline
Registered User
Comedy Jobber For Life: AKA Santino
 
Join Date: Jan 2009
Posts: 354
neildittmar is looking to come up from OCW...neildittmar is looking to come up from OCW...neildittmar is looking to come up from OCW...neildittmar is looking to come up from OCW...neildittmar is looking to come up from OCW...
Default

Sting going over Hogan and winning the championship is exactly how Starrcade 1997 should have closed. How it specifically went down, as you illustrated in your very detailed post, was ludicrous.

The nWo had been running roughshod over nearly the entire roster for the better part of a year and a half. Hogan in particular had been booked (or perhaps booked himself) as an unstoppable heel despite playing the coward. Everyone knew that wherever Hogan was, the nWo was close behind and would be the deciding factor in any confrontation. Sting was the hero that could somehow miraculously even the odds. All the pieces were in play for WCW's biggest show of the year.

As far as the match goes, I had no problem with Hogan beating on Sting for the majority of the bout. I also, generally speaking, had no trouble with Bret Hart ultimately being used the way he was as well. I can even buy a semi-screwy finish where Hogan has some type of claim that he never lost the title clean... for example, although cliché the old "ref bump" and knockout could've done the trick here. Sting scorpion death locks Hogan, Hart comes in and makes the call for the submission, bell is rung and Sting's the champ. That allows the Hogan/Sting angle to go on past Starrcade (if that was the intention) and still send the fans home happy.

The problem was there were too many cooks in the kitchen or better yet, ingredients in the recipe. I'm a big proponent of wrestling being best when it's simple and straightforward. Hero Sting vs. Villain Hogan was perfect. Babyface beating the odds and winning against a seemingly insurmountable force in the nWo? Check! Hart's cameo? Fine. The ingredients that didn't belong were Hogan's creative clause (fast count) and the fact that Bischoff just had to invoke the Montreal Screw Job in the match. Those two events turned the bout into the mess that it became.

Less than a year later, WCW found themselves with lightning in a bottle one more time with Goldberg / Hogan. In one respect, all involved likely learned from their previous mistake with Goldberg going over Hogan clean in a huge match. The problem? It wasn't built up nearly as well as Sting / Hogan in my opinion and the payoff occurred at a random Nitro in July as opposed to, oh say Starrcade 1998.

Of course, we all know what happened at Starrcade '98... an event perhaps even more egregious than what took place a year prior and a story for another thread.
sendpm.gif Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 06-30-2017, 02:46 AM
shooter_mcgavin shooter_mcgavin is offline
Registered User
ROH Pure Champion
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 1,416
shooter_mcgavin scored a win over Santino Marella...shooter_mcgavin scored a win over Santino Marella...shooter_mcgavin scored a win over Santino Marella...shooter_mcgavin scored a win over Santino Marella...shooter_mcgavin scored a win over Santino Marella...shooter_mcgavin scored a win over Santino Marella...shooter_mcgavin scored a win over Santino Marella...shooter_mcgavin scored a win over Santino Marella...shooter_mcgavin scored a win over Santino Marella...shooter_mcgavin scored a win over Santino Marella...shooter_mcgavin scored a win over Santino Marella...
Default

Not sure if it killed WCW since the rise of Goldberg gave WCW a second change to set things right.

But yes Starrcade 1997 did take a big hit on WCW and, add the fact the nWo was still the predominant storyline in WCW and Austin was slowly rising as huge superstar, it made the company very vulnerable.

Quote:
Originally Posted by neildittmar View Post
Sting going over Hogan and winning the championship is exactly how Starrcade 1997 should have closed. How it specifically went down, as you illustrated in your very detailed post, was ludicrous.
Also Bash at the Beach 1998 should have been Hogan, Hall, and Nash vs. Sting, Luger, and <Savage, Goldberg, The Giant, or DDP> for a "Winner Takes All Match" to end the NWO.
sendpm.gif Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 06-30-2017, 05:28 AM
Jonyboyuk2 Jonyboyuk2 is offline
Registered User
WWE Diva's Champion
 
Join Date: Feb 2012
Posts: 459
Jonyboyuk2 is looking to come up from OCW...Jonyboyuk2 is looking to come up from OCW...Jonyboyuk2 is looking to come up from OCW...Jonyboyuk2 is looking to come up from OCW...Jonyboyuk2 is looking to come up from OCW...Jonyboyuk2 is looking to come up from OCW...Jonyboyuk2 is looking to come up from OCW...
Default

There were hundreds of incidents that led to WCW's demise. This was certainly a bad PPV ending. What should have happened is Bret Hart should have run in at the end instead of being an enforcer. NWO should have all been taking cheap shots on Sting through the match giving Hogan the huge advantage, and then WCW wrestlers should have come out and taken on NWO in the aisle whilst Bret ran through the middle and dropped Hogan leaving Sting to win the title and set up a Hogan V Bret feud. They could have gone to a double DQ at Souled Out 98, and then been kept apart for a year whilst they built the match up. Bret Hart could have played the Good Guy trying to get Heel Hogan to come back good. Such a shame WCW went the way it did.
sendpm.gif Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 06-30-2017, 08:04 AM
Greg4WWE Greg4WWE is offline
Registered User
 
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 176
Greg4WWE is looking to come up from OCW...Greg4WWE is looking to come up from OCW...
Default

Oh how I remember all this like it was yesterday. Hard to believe it's been 20 freaking years.

It started perfect. Sting being confused. But if you remember, he still talked a bit at the start of this transformation. Remember the whole, "The only thing that is sure about Sting is, nothing's for sure"? promo when NWO offered him to join them?

Anyway, it was all fine and dandy, until the Nitro a couple weeks prior to Starccade they finally trapped Sting and beat him down. Right there, IMO, his year and a half run of seemingly not being able to be hurt came tumbling down. I know most wrestling storylines have the good guy getting beat up before a PPV, this particular story didn't need it though. It was already perfect. Sting and Hogan barely laying a finger on each other leading up to it.

The match came, and yeah. Hogan dominated. Not even an early match flurry from Sting really, Hogan was in charge most of this match. Just dumb dumb dumb. Of course Hogan should have had some spots in the match where he looks in control, but not that dominate. I think it would have been better had Hogan used a foreign object to hit Sting then cover him. Fans think Hogan has won, then, OUT COMES BRET HART, match is restarted and Sting wins. THAT would have been ok too.

To make matters worse, this 18 months of build up to a PPV, and we got a HOgan vs Sting rematch the next night on Nitro that didn't even end during TV time. And the following week, Sting was stripped of the title. WHY? None of it made no sense. It was at this point I realized WCW didn't care to finish storylines. One thing would lead into another with no pay off.

Sting was still great after this, but the aura he built for 18 months was gone almost in an instant. WCW slow decline started that night. I agree. Russo came in soon after and put the final bullet in the brain.
sendpm.gif Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 06-30-2017, 08:54 AM
rokuma's Avatar
rokuma rokuma is offline
The Legend
Comedy Jobber For Life: AKA Santino
 
Join Date: Jul 2009
Posts: 246
rokuma is looking to come up from OCW...rokuma is looking to come up from OCW...rokuma is looking to come up from OCW...
Send a message via ICQ to rokuma Send a message via AIM to rokuma
Default

I've thought about Starrcade 1997 a lot and I've always thought that it should've went like this:

First of all, this is important: Bret Hart DOES NOT show up at Starrcade at all.
They make no mention of him joining WCW before this and he does not referee Bischoff/Zybsko. He's absent, PERIOD.

Sting/Hogan have their normal match and Sting gets the upperhand and the NWO runs down (as always) to interfere and as Sting had done for months, he battles back and banishes the NWO from the ring. It's at this point, that the locker room just empties and WCW finally bands together to get rid of the NWO. There were a ton of WCW wrestlers in the crowd...they jump the rails too and just attacks the NWO and the NWO gets driven up the ramp. WCW just blocks the ramp and creates a wall keeping the NWO from getting involved again.

In the meantime, someone slipped Hogan the WCW title belt and as Sting is distracted by all of this Hogan drills him and then hits the legdrop. Fans think Hogan's going to win and Sting kicks out at 2. Hogan can't believe it. Sting does his version of a "hulk up" pounding his chest and such. Goes crazy on Hogan. Stinger splash, Stinger splash, Scorpion Deathlock and Hogan GIVES UP in the middle of the ring. Sting's your champion, WCW hits the ring to celebrate, the crowd goes nuts, etc.

The next night on Nitro to close the show you have two choices: A)The NWO is disbanded or option 2) This scenario: The NWO is in the ring. Nash is berating Hogan for dropping the ball, etc. The NWO turns on Hulk Hogan and then Bret Hart runs down to save Hogan with a chair and the NWO backs up. Then Bret blasts Hogan with the chair and pulls what he did to Vince McMahon at Wrestlemania 26 and just destroys Hogan with a chair. Nash hits the Jackknife. Maybe Hall hits the Outsider's Edge or whatever. Then Hart locks in the Sharpshooter and Hogan is basically written off until Halloween Havoc, returning with no NWO and WCW not trusting him. Eventually this leads to Hogan/Hart at Starrcade 1998.

Obviously this is all fantasy booking and Hulk Hogan would've had to have agreed with all of these ideas and that wasn't a foregone conclusion at that point in WCW. The fascinating thing about scenario 2 is we never get Hogan/Goldberg on Nitro. If Goldberg had continued on and had his match against either Bret Hart as champion or Sting (7 months into his WCW reign and looking unstoppable) does it have the same effect on Bill Goldberg?

Either way, the way WCW played it was poor and it remains a huge "what-if" in wrestling today.
sendpm.gif Reply With Quote
  #8  
Old 06-30-2017, 08:54 AM
shooter_mcgavin shooter_mcgavin is offline
Registered User
ROH Pure Champion
 
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 1,416
shooter_mcgavin scored a win over Santino Marella...shooter_mcgavin scored a win over Santino Marella...shooter_mcgavin scored a win over Santino Marella...shooter_mcgavin scored a win over Santino Marella...shooter_mcgavin scored a win over Santino Marella...shooter_mcgavin scored a win over Santino Marella...shooter_mcgavin scored a win over Santino Marella...shooter_mcgavin scored a win over Santino Marella...shooter_mcgavin scored a win over Santino Marella...shooter_mcgavin scored a win over Santino Marella...shooter_mcgavin scored a win over Santino Marella...
Default

Anyways the best analogy I can use with WCW and the Starrcade 97 finish is Rocky IV in the fight with Rocky and Drago.

Drago was seen as unstoppable but after Rocky cut Drago they found that Drago was beatable and is human. Which eventually led Rocky knocking out Drago.

The Starrcade 97 finish is the the cut Rocky delivered to Drago in Rocky IV.
sendpm.gif Reply With Quote
  #9  
Old 06-30-2017, 09:57 AM
enviousdominous's Avatar
enviousdominous enviousdominous is offline
Behold my diction
WCW TV Champion
 
Join Date: Jun 2011
Location: Florida
Posts: 1,731
enviousdominous is going to make some noise in the draft...enviousdominous is going to make some noise in the draft...enviousdominous is going to make some noise in the draft...enviousdominous is going to make some noise in the draft...enviousdominous is going to make some noise in the draft...enviousdominous is going to make some noise in the draft...enviousdominous is going to make some noise in the draft...enviousdominous is going to make some noise in the draft...enviousdominous is going to make some noise in the draft...enviousdominous is going to make some noise in the draft...enviousdominous is going to make some noise in the draft...
Default

I think that the message that WCW was trying to send with having Sting hand a bat to Rick Steiner and then turn his back only to have Scott stop Rick from attacking Sting, was that Sting was testing their ability to strike him down in an homage to the whole "let he who is without sin" parable. I thought it was brilliant storytelling at the time (I was only 15 though).

I was always a casual WCW fan, so I didn't buy the PPV. I remember Nitro being a very confusing show the next night. There was minimal talk of a fast count, and Hogan was all "I BEAT STING IN THE MIDDLE OF THAT RING! ONE! TWO! THREE!" and he kept on motioning with his arm as if he was the ref counting the fall.

So, they had a rematch at SuperBrawl. Randy Savage hit Hogan with a spraypaint can, and Sting therefore won without being allowed a clean pin.

I think that WCW hit a creative dead end at that point and were desperately trying to make what they had work again. Sting would get lost in the mess that was the NWO Wolfpac vs NWO Hollywood angle, and the fingerpoke of doom would come not long after that.
__________________
There is nothing either good or bad, but thinking makes it so. - Hamlet
sendpm.gif Reply With Quote
  #10  
Old 06-30-2017, 11:17 PM
sikkbones's Avatar
sikkbones sikkbones is offline
Registered User
Comedy Jobber For Life: AKA Santino
 
Join Date: May 2010
Posts: 335
sikkbones is looking to come up from OCW...sikkbones is looking to come up from OCW...sikkbones is looking to come up from OCW...sikkbones is looking to come up from OCW...
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by rokuma View Post
I've thought about Starrcade 1997 a lot and I've always thought that it should've went like this:

First of all, this is important: Bret Hart DOES NOT show up at Starrcade at all.
They make no mention of him joining WCW before this and he does not referee Bischoff/Zybsko. He's absent, PERIOD.

Sting/Hogan have their normal match and Sting gets the upperhand and the NWO runs down (as always) to interfere and as Sting had done for months, he battles back and banishes the NWO from the ring. It's at this point, that the locker room just empties and WCW finally bands together to get rid of the NWO. There were a ton of WCW wrestlers in the crowd...they jump the rails too and just attacks the NWO and the NWO gets driven up the ramp. WCW just blocks the ramp and creates a wall keeping the NWO from getting involved again.

In the meantime, someone slipped Hogan the WCW title belt and as Sting is distracted by all of this Hogan drills him and then hits the legdrop. Fans think Hogan's going to win and Sting kicks out at 2. Hogan can't believe it. Sting does his version of a "hulk up" pounding his chest and such. Goes crazy on Hogan. Stinger splash, Stinger splash, Scorpion Deathlock and Hogan GIVES UP in the middle of the ring. Sting's your champion, WCW hits the ring to celebrate, the crowd goes nuts, etc.

The next night on Nitro to close the show you have two choices: A)The NWO is disbanded or option 2) This scenario: The NWO is in the ring. Nash is berating Hogan for dropping the ball, etc. The NWO turns on Hulk Hogan and then Bret Hart runs down to save Hogan with a chair and the NWO backs up. Then Bret blasts Hogan with the chair and pulls what he did to Vince McMahon at Wrestlemania 26 and just destroys Hogan with a chair. Nash hits the Jackknife. Maybe Hall hits the Outsider's Edge or whatever. Then Hart locks in the Sharpshooter and Hogan is basically written off until Halloween Havoc, returning with no NWO and WCW not trusting him. Eventually this leads to Hogan/Hart at Starrcade 1998.

Obviously this is all fantasy booking and Hulk Hogan would've had to have agreed with all of these ideas and that wasn't a foregone conclusion at that point in WCW. The fascinating thing about scenario 2 is we never get Hogan/Goldberg on Nitro. If Goldberg had continued on and had his match against either Bret Hart as champion or Sting (7 months into his WCW reign and looking unstoppable) does it have the same effect on Bill Goldberg?

Either way, the way WCW played it was poor and it remains a huge "what-if" in wrestling today.
This would have been a great way to revitalise a saggy nwo instead of another year or two of hogan.

Bret hart would have actually worked as nwo 2.0s leader in early 1998.
__________________


the Five Moves of doom?
sendpm.gif Reply With Quote
Reply


Thread Tools Search this Thread
Search this Thread:

Advanced Search
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:38 AM.

monitoring_string = "afb8e5d7348ab9e99f73cba908f10802"
Contact Us - Clear Cookies - Lost Password - WrestleZone Forums - Archive - Privacy Statement - Terms of Use - Top - AdChoices