Winner's Bracket Debate #8: Talon -vs- Mitch Hennessey

[CH David]

Clarity - I liked Talon's opener. It was what I ask for, but I feel that Mitch's was just better. Very concise throughout, and Mitch's conclusion certainly helped.

Point - R.J. MacReady

Punctuality - Talon was quicker throughout.

Point - The Talon

Informative - Videos to help your argument are great. Mitch did a great job with multiple videos in his final post. Use evidence to support your argument!

Point - R.J. MacReady

Persuasion - Mitch was overwhelming in this one though. Pounced on his prey and just tore through him. That's not so much to say Talon didn't do a solid job, but more that Mitch was just better.

Points - R.J. MacReady

Talon, you did a nice job with this. A lot better than I had originally anticipated at the start of this debate. Keep the solid work going forward.

CH David scores this R.J. MacReady 4, The Talon 1.

[FunKay P. Lovecraft]

Clarity: Decent breakdown's, but Mitch's was first, and Talon did manage to even mess up his choice. That's kinda a knock back from the start.

Punctuality: Consistent and quciker was Talon (Yoda become I have?).

Informative: The experienced deabter in Mitch wins this. He used video evidence to further his points, and made his arguments better than Talon's. This of course suggests that Mitch also takes...

Persuasion: Again, Mitch's. Talon made some good points, but he just could not cope with the heavyweight it Mitch. Good showing though.

FunKay Scores It: Mitch: 4, Talon: 1

[Nate]

Clarity- I'll give it to Mitch. Talon's structure wasn't bad, but Mitch's was better.

Point- Mitch

Punctuation- Talon was faster.

Point- Talon

Informative- Talon wasn't bad here, but Mitch, ever the veteran, knew what it took and came heavy with the videos and whatnot. Good stuff.

Point- Mitch

Persuasion- This wasn't the runaway I thought it would be. Talon did make some very solid points, but Mitch bringing up the PPV match comparison is what drove it home for me. At least the TV Title is featured on PPV pretty regularly.

Point- Mitch

Nate score is Mitch 4, Talon 1.

[D-Man]

Unfortunately, even if Talon gets a perfect score from SavageTaker, he cannot win this bracket. Therefore, R.J. MacReady (Mitch Hennessey) has clinched his defeat over Talon by a score of 12-3. He will move onto Winner's bracket #16 while Talon moves down to Loser's bracket #12.

Good work.