View Single Post
  #33  
Old 12-30-2017, 06:09 PM
Mighty NorCal's Avatar
Mighty NorCal Mighty NorCal is offline
SHALL WE BEGIN?
Wrestlezone Hall of Famer
 
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Velen
Posts: 8,837
Mighty NorCal is a WWE Champion...Mighty NorCal is a WWE Champion...Mighty NorCal is a WWE Champion...Mighty NorCal is a WWE Champion...Mighty NorCal is a WWE Champion...Mighty NorCal is a WWE Champion...Mighty NorCal is a WWE Champion...Mighty NorCal is a WWE Champion...Mighty NorCal is a WWE Champion...Mighty NorCal is a WWE Champion...Mighty NorCal is a WWE Champion...
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dagger Dias View Post
No it wasn't. Here is a listing of the 2017 WWE PPV events.

Royal Rumble
Elimination Chamber
Fastlane
Wrestlemania 33
Payback
Backlash
Extreme Rules
Money In The Bank
Great Balls Of Fire
Battleground
Summerslam
No Mercy
Hell In A Cell
Tables, Ladders & Chairs
Survivor Series
Clash of Champions

There's a lot of shows on that list. It contains some very good shows and even some bad ones. You know what I do NOT see on there? The Mae Young Classic. Why you might ask? It's not listed amongst the 2017 WWE PPV events because it wasn't a PPV. You can play the "Why because you said so?" card all you want, but that works both ways. The Mae Young Classic does not suddenly become retconned into becoming a PPV just because NorCal said so. The fact of the matter is that it was NOT a PPV. Period.

.
So its your position that Takeovers are not the same as the big shows WWE puts on? That they would not qualify for the type of thing the OP is asking about? unless its purchased and put on a screen at Buffalo Wild Wings it doesn't count now?


Quote:
Originally Posted by Dagger Dias View Post

There was not a single person in the entire list of participants who was in the WWE during the tournament. A few have had appearances in NXT battle royals or as jobbers, but nothing of major note. Sarah Logan did not make it to the main roster until after the tournament. So, unless you count someone being Miz's makeup artist or the two women who were once part of Adam Rose's Rosebuds, or Serena's run from 7 years ago.... A grand total of NOBODY from the Mae Young Classic was in the WWE.... AND none of the women from the main rosters were in the tournament. The event did not feature anyone from the WWE. Nice try.
Only the main roster counts as being in WWE now? You know that NXT isn't an actual separate promotion, right ?


Quote:
Originally Posted by Dagger Dias View Post

We've covered this. The women of Raw and Smackdown have never had a PPV event before. Neither have the NXT women had an all women's Takeover event. So as has yet to be demonstrated, we do not know. Hence the topic of discussion.
So Takeovers DO count? Even though they do not fufill your own definition of a "PPV" ?

Further....What is different between an all female Takeover and the MYC? Nothing, would be the answer.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Dagger Dias View Post

Just because it was a one-time event does not make it a PPV. NXT Takeovers are a little more gray. With that being said, The Mae Young Classic was not an all women's NXT Takeover, let alone an all women's WWE PPV. An all women's WWE PPV has to have WWE personnel in it. Otherwise it's irrelevant to the discussion.
There were multiple NXT talents in the MYC. NXT talents are WWE personnel. NXT talent are also, incidentally, NXT personnel (for a Takeover). Takeovers have also featured non-WWE talent.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Dagger Dias View Post
. However, Kairi got nothing and she could have gotten her title shot without this tournament.
The...title shot she got for winning the tournament? Are you seriously referencing the title shot she got from winning the tournament in the same sentence saying she got nothing from winning the tournament? Has Rick Fucking James inhabited your body?

A title shot for the winner was always the prize, btw.
__________________
Quote:
Originally Posted by Slyfox696 View Post
Although, I can see where the subtlety of that would escape you.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Slyfox696 View Post
Perhaps, then, you really are an idiot?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Great White Sam View Post
If there's one thing missing from Britain's annual Royal Rumble meet-ups, it's us chucking each other about in excitement.

Last edited by Mighty NorCal : 12-30-2017 at 06:21 PM.
sendpm.gif Reply With Quote